8.06.2009

Reconciling Self Deception By Way Of Self Deception

Share
I occasionally read christian blogs and news feeds just to see what those wacky sky worshipers are up to and to give myself some perspective. Most of what I read is generally polite and interesting and even if I don't agree with it, I at least learn a thing or two from what I've read. Today I ran across a book review on christianity today that I felt was interesting to a certain point. I feel like this is indicative of what I usually encounter on these sites - logic, logic, logic, god. And god is almost always the dead end.

The book which was being discussed was I Told Me So: The Role of Self-Deception in Christian Living by Gregg A. Ten Elshof. Pontification aside, the point of the book as explained by the reviewer seems sound and applicable to anyone, not just those of the christian faith:
The abilities that contribute to self-deception are not wrong in themselves. People go wrong when they use their deceiving abilities to convince themselves that they are better than they actually are: "If I'm not so bad, I don't have to change."
Makes sense and in all honesty this is a pretty basic point. Self deception (they cite setting your alarm ahead 15 minutes so that you don't wake up late as an example) is not always bad, it's only destructive when the self decption results in a negative impact on yourself or others which is additionally somehow rationalized by the person inflicting the damage as not their fault or concern. The book evidently reconciles this by stating the following:
How does one avoid self-deception's negative effects? Ten Elshof offers several helpful strategies: Recognize that everyone does it, put real plans into action that prevent the need to deceive oneself, welcome honest and diverse feedback, and ultimately, seek the Holy Spirit's guidance to reveal the truth.
This bothers me. As an atheist I see the whole 'holy spirit' figure as a kind of self deception, so in essence this author is suggesting that the negative effects of self deception can be avoided by participating in...more self deception.

I understand that religious people don't see their myth the same way I do and for them this seeking out of the holy spirit is something so real to them it can't possibly be categorized as self deception in the same way rationalizing cheating or lying is, but essentially the rationalizing of a lie is performed by having a conversation with yourself. I can't see the whole looking to the holy spirit for guidance thing as anything more than just another conversation with yourself, only in that instance you're not only mulling something over in your own head, you're additionally pretending that your own head is something far more grandiose (and therefore more worthy of consideration regardless of how crazy the end result of the conversation may be) than yourself. That kind of make believe seems far more dangerous to me than any reality based self deception out there.

Comment (1)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Gregg Ten Elshof's avatar

Gregg Ten Elshof · 815 weeks ago

...poking around for posts related to my book and found this one. Thanks for these thoughtful remarks. I agree that the topic of self-deception has broader application. I was mostly interested in exploring the various manifestations of S.D. in my own sub-culture (Christian groups). In the book I occasionally make reference to S.D. in other sub-cultures (including atheists). Of course, it's not surprising that talk of communication with the Holy Spirit would look like just so much more S.D. from your perspective. Since the book is primarily written to fellow Christians about how S.D. shows up in their groups, I presuppose quite a bit of Christian theology.

If you have a chance to read the book, I'd love to hear your thoughts about the more general principles and about how you think S.D. shows up in your groups.

If you're interested, I did an interview about the book with the folks at the Evangelical Philosophical Society website here: http://www.epsociety.org/blog/labels/I%20told%20m...

Thanks again for your interest in the book.
Cheers!
GT

Post a new comment

Comments by